Profile
Back to NewsBack
Dev.to 20 min
Reader Mode
Monuments of India, Part 3: Sixteen Statues Sculpted from Photographs, a Rebuilt Mysore Palace and More

Monuments of India, Part 3: Sixteen Statues Sculpted from Photographs, a Rebuilt Mysore Palace and More

1 day ago

In Part 2 I went through the shared kit that every building in Monuments of India is made from: domes, kiosks, pillars, arches, temple towers. That kit made the famous buildings look much better. It also showed what was still crude. The statues were smooth figures without faces you could read, and several were stand-ins: a generic "leader" figure for Netaji, a seated Buddha for Adi Shankaracharya, Hindu deities on the roofs of Kolkata's Victoria Memorial. The Nandis, elephants and lions guarding the temples were simple shapes. The boats and traffic were boxes. And several monuments still looked like massing models, with the right shape and height but plain walls and empty courts.

This post covers the round of work that went after all of that:

  1. Statues: every free-standing statue sculpted again from photographs, sixteen in all, from the Statue of Unity to the lion and tiger on the gates of Mumbai's Victoria Terminus.
  2. Animals and figures: Nandi, temple elephants, lions, war horses, door guardians and frieze figures.
  3. Boats, ships, traffic and guns: cargo ships, Kashmiri houseboats, the traffic on Kolkata's and Mumbai's bridges, and the Kargil memorial's guns.
  4. Architecture: about thirty new shared parts and new surfaces, finer detail on more than forty monuments, and Mysore Palace rebuilt from a photograph.
  5. A bigger triangle budget: 800k on desktops instead of 650k, spent on the buildings and not the trees.

Most pictures below are before-and-after pairs, rendered by the project's own screenshot scripts.

Statues

The statues are not built from boxes and cylinders. Each one is a signed distance field, a function that tells you how far any point is from the figure's skin, turned into a mesh. Until now each statue was meshed on one grid. That meant a choice: a fine grid everywhere was too many triangles, and a coarse one gave the head no face.

The sculpting function now takes a list of fine regions. The part of the figure inside a region, usually an ellipsoid round the head, is meshed on its own finer grid, and the rest on the main grid. The two parts overlap slightly at the seam, and each is drawn just inside the skin past its cut, so they meet in one clean line. This is how Nandi's head gets 3.5 cm cells while its body has 8 cm:

sculpt('nandi', nandiField, {
  h: 0.08,            // body: 8 cm cells
  wear: 0.4,          // ridges rubbed pale, as polished stone is
  split: {            // head: its own finer grid
    region: E([0, 2.38, 2.25], [0.9, 1.15, 0.78]), // ellipsoid crossing the neck
    h: 0.035,
    lo: [-1.0, 1.1, 1.4], hi: [1.0, 3.5, 3.05],
  },
});

Two more tools came with it: wear, which rubs the ridges pale (worked out from the field's curvature), and snap(), a way to lay curves and parts on the skin, such as buttons, creepers, hems and jewellery, so they follow the surface instead of floating beside it.

The biggest change in how the statues are made is that hands, faces and feet are no longer separate meshes stuck onto a body. They are sculpted in the body, as one skin, with fine regions that follow them. The Statue of Unity was done this way first, and then every other statue was brought up to the same standard and checked against photographs.

Here is every statue in the project now. The components page has the same gallery with a table of what each one is and where it's built:

Statue of Unity Gommateshwara Thiruvalluvar
Sardar Patel, Statue of Unity Bahubali, Gommateshwara Thiruvalluvar, Kanyakumari
Nageshwar Shiva Adi Shankaracharya Statue of Oneness
The seated Shiva, Nageshwar Adi Shankaracharya, Kedarnath Statue of Oneness, Omkareshwar
Netaji Shivaji Angel of Victory and Queen Victoria
Netaji, India Gate Shivaji, Gateway of India Angel of Victory and Queen Victoria
Allegories Progress Commerce and Agriculture
Justice, Prudence, Motherhood, Learning, Britannia Progress, Victoria Terminus Commerce and Agriculture, Victoria Terminus
Gajalakshmi Lion Capital, lion and tiger
Gajalakshmi, Mysore Palace The Lion Capital; the lion and tiger of Victoria Terminus

The four great statues

The Statue of Unity was redone from photographs, layer by layer, then checked against them again:

  • The head: the face from the 1949 portrait, a little smaller and bowed, with a heavy brow, deep-set open eyes under heavy lids, forehead lines, a strong nose, deep folds to a set mouth, jowls and ears.
  • The upper body in three layers: a short square shawl to the elbows with a turned-up hem and creases over the arms. Under it is the bandi, a sleeveless jacket with a band collar, eight buttons, a chest pocket and two flapped pockets, with a wide opening that the viewing gallery's windows sit across. Below that is an A-line kurta. The kurta sleeves and the loose fists are sculpted in the body; the separate mesh hands are gone.
  • The dhoti: full, in long diagonal folds round each leg and hanging in swags between them, narrowing to an uneven hem above the ankle.
  • The feet: bare shins and chappals with a shaped sole, a strap over the instep and a toe ring, and five toes. Before, they were boot-like lumps on flat discs.
  • The bronze: a new plates surface draws the cladding as joined bronze panels, with joints worked out in 3D space so they run true over the curved body. The colour is now the dull olive-gold of the real statue, and the plate joints are softened.

The plinth also gained the museum's glazed entrance at the top of the front steps, and stone fins between the bronze panels of the top tier.

Before After
Statue of Unity before Statue of Unity after

Gommateshwara, the monolith at Shravanabelagola, now stands at its real 17.4 m:

  • The head is meshed at 4.5 cm: almond eyes under lowered lids, arched brows, a straight nose, a smiling mouth, long flat earlobes, and small curls in rows on the scalp.
  • The legs are carved as massive columns, the thighs meeting from the groin to the knees, on large feet with toes. The shoulders slope as they do in the stone.
  • The hands have a flat palm, four long separate fingers and a thumb, meshed on fine cells, resting on two taller anthills that are one stone with the legs and carved with spiral scrolls.
  • The madhavi creepers rise from between the feet, sweep out across the thighs in a V and wind up the arms to a coil below the shoulder, in granite, in low relief on the skin. Before, they floated in green beside the limbs.
Before After
Gommateshwara before Gommateshwara after

Thiruvalluvar at Kanyakumari is 29 m tall on the Alankara Mandapam, now a pilastered granite hall with a terrace and parapet. The face, beard, moustache, hair knot and hands are sculpted in the body. He's turned so the right hand is raised before the chest and the left holds a bound palm-leaf manuscript at the waist, with the hips swaying and the feet under the hem. The real statue is built of stacked granite blocks, so a new blocks surface draws the joints between them.

The Shiva at Nageshwar was blue on a pink lotus. It's now as photographed: terracotta in colour, sitting in the half lotus with the left foot tucked under the right knee and the right foot lying sole up on the thigh, with toes and anklets. Four arms hold the trishul and a large damru, with Om on the raised palm. The face and hands are sculpted in the body, with painted eyes under lowered lids, a painted band of ash and the third eye. There are two malas in a V, a cobra with its hood upright beside the ear, snake armlets, tiger skins falling over the lap and shoulder, and the hair combed up into a knot with a pale crescent, on a rock seat with a tiger head.

Before After
Nageshwar before Nageshwar after

Statues that were stand-ins

Several monuments had a statue in the right place but the wrong figure in it, borrowed from the kit. These were all sculpted from photographs.

  • Netaji at India Gate was the kit's generic "leader". He's now 8.5 m of black granite as one skin: saluting in INA uniform, the right hand flat at the edge of the side cap and the left fist at his side, round spectacles, a tunic with collar, shoulder straps, four flapped pockets and belt, breeches flaring over the thighs, and knee boots, with the uncut stone left behind the calves. The saluting hand uses a new slab() shape in the SDF library.
  • Shivaji at the Gateway of India was a cylinder-and-ball rider on one of Konark's horses. Now the bronze horse prances with its left foreleg raised (a new prance option on the horse), and the rider sits upright in angarkha, sash and baldric, a round shield on his back, the reins in his left hand and a curved sword held low along the flank, under a Maratha turban with plume and tassel. The tapering stone pedestal carries the shield and crossed swords and stands in a railed lawn.
  • The Statue of Oneness at Omkareshwar shows the young Shankaracharya walking, the staff across his body with a cloth bundle at its top, a water pot in his left hand, a long mala and rudraksha bands, in copper-toned bronze on an open lotus. It's meshed coarsely enough to keep the monument within its phone budget.
  • Adi Shankaracharya at Kedarnath was the kit's seated Buddha. He's now black stone, seated cross-legged (a new crossLegged() figure), with long hair, three rudraksha malas, the right hand raised in the gesture of teaching holding the flagged staff and the left on the knee with a palm-leaf book, on a great lotus bud on a post in a pool.
Before: the kit's generic figure After: Netaji, sculpted from photographs
Kit statue before Netaji after

Allegories for the colonial buildings

The Victoria Memorial and Victoria Terminus (CSMT) were using Hindu deity figures, the Buddha and Khajuraho poses on their roofs, because those were what the kit had. Their real statues are classical allegories, so there's now a kit for those: women in classical drapery sculpted as one skin, standing, seated (on a block or a throne, with a mantle, a child or an infant) or winged, with named arm poses and a head in hair, a veil and crown, or a helmet. And there's a set of things for them to hold: torch, sword, scales, mirror, book, palette, square, trident, caduceus, ship, plough, cornucopia, sheaf, sickle, wreath, trumpet, sceptre, orb, shield, winged wheel and star.

  • Victoria Memorial: the bronze Angel of Victory on top, winged and poised on her ball with a bugle to her lips and a wreath; Queen Victoria enthroned in the robes of the Star of India with crown, veil, sceptre and orb; Art, Architecture, Justice and Charity round the dome; Motherhood with Prudence and Learning over the north porch; and robed figures on the pavilion corners and the balustrade.
  • CSMT: Progress in marble on the dome, torch aloft and her hand on a winged wheel; the groups of Commerce and Agriculture over the forward wings' gables; robed figures by the clock; and the lion and tiger lying on the gate piers.

On phones the allegories become a light robed pose, which keeps both buildings within budget.

Animals and figures

The same sculpting tools went into the animals and figures that appear across dozens of monuments, so one improvement shows up everywhere they're used.

Nandi now has its head meshed at 3.5 cm, nostrils, mouth and lids, a saddle blanket with a raised border draped over its back, a strand of beads over the garland of bells, a larger bell at the chest, anklets and a tail tuft.

Before After
Nandi before Nandi after

Elephants have a wrinkled trunk, rimmed ears, lidded eyes, a mouth and toenails. The dressed temple elephants are the bigger change. Their cloth, its gold border, the painted forehead and the nettipattam (the gold caparison on Kerala's temple elephants) used to be flat boxes and tilted plates. Now they're cast as thin shells on the skin, studded with bosses, with the bell rope laid round the neck. Elephants can also raise their trunks now, which is how the two beside Gajalakshmi at Mysore Palace pour water from their pots.

Before After
Elephants before Elephants after

Lions are carved as temple gates carve them: a mane of curls in rows, a heavy brow over bulging eyes, the mouth open on fangs and a tongue, claws on the forepaws, a collar with a bell, and the tail curled up over the haunch to a flame-like tuft. The same lion now makes the Lion Capital on the National War Memorial, four lions back to back over the lotus bell (it used to be boxes and balls), and a lying-down couchant() pose for the lion and tiger at CSMT.

Horses follow Konark's war horses: muscled shoulders and quarters, proper knees, hocks and hooves, the mane carved in strands, and a full tail. They also have a bridle with cheek straps and noseband, a plume between the ears, bells on the breast collar and a saddle cloth.

Before After
Horse and lion before Horse and lion after

Door guardians (dvarapalas) now have fierce faces, earrings, a tiered crown, necklace, armlets, belt and sash, and a ribbed club. Frieze figures, the rows of small carved people on temple walls, have a face with brow, nose and chin, and a tiered crown instead of a cone.

Door guardian

All this detail is tiered by size and device. A large lion on a desktop gets its head and mane meshed at 3 cm, while a small one in a frieze, or any lion on a phone, gets a coarser version.

Ships, boats, traffic and guns

The setting around each monument matters as much as the monument, and some of the props were still boxes.

Cargo ships in the harbours (off the Gateway of India, for example) are now proper general cargo ships about 90 m long. Each has a dark hull with red boot-topping and a white sheer line, hatch covers on the well deck, king posts with derricks, and a white superstructure in four tiers with a banded funnel. On desktops they also get window rows, bridge wings, lifeboats in davits, railings, anchors, a foremast and a radar mast.

Before After
Ships before Ships after

Kashmiri houseboats have a long cedar hull with the bow raked up out of the water, a carved walnut-dark cabin under a gabled roof, and an open verandah at the bow with a carved railing and a fretted valance. On desktops they also get window frames and mullions, balusters, a ridge rail and a name board.

Before After
Houseboats before Houseboats after

Traffic on the Howrah Bridge and the Bandra–Worli Sea Link is drawn from side profiles: saloons, Kolkata's yellow Ambassador taxis with their rounded bonnet and tall glasshouse, buses with a band of windows, and trucks with a painted wooden body under a tarpaulin. On desktops they also have lights, bumpers and destination boards, and phones get every other vehicle.

Before After
Traffic before Traffic after

The Kargil War Memorial now shows the guns of the war on its plaza. There are three towed 155 mm howitzers modelled on the Bofors guns, each with its barrel and muzzle brake, recoil cylinders, shield, two big wheels and a split trail. In front is a row of plinths with the captured weapons: mortars, twin anti-aircraft guns and heavy machine guns on tripods.

Before After
Kargil War Memorial before Kargil War Memorial after

Architecture

New parts in the kit

Most of the architectural gains come from new shared parts. Each is written once and then used wherever it belongs:

Manastambha Deepmala Nandi mandapa
Manastambha Deepmala (lamp tower) Nandi mandapa
Muqarnas Pranala Prayer wheels
Iwan with muqarnas and an inscription band Pranala (water spout) Prayer wheels
Machicolation Copper roofs Chadar
Machicolation Copper and gilded-copper roofs Chadar (water cascade)

Temples

  • Manastambha: the pillar of honour in front of a Jain temple, optionally with four seated tirthankaras in its top pavilion.
  • Deepmala: Maharashtra's stone lamp tower, with rings of arms each carrying a brass lamp that lights at night.
  • Nandi mandapa: the open pavilion on the temple's axis where Nandi faces the sanctum.
  • Kerala gable: the carved timber mukhappu set into Kerala's temple roofs.
  • Dravida hall dress: a moulded base, pilasters, a curved kapota eave and a parapet of miniature shrines, for any plain South Indian hall or shrine block.
  • Carved door jambs (shakhas): columns of small figures in niches up the doorway, with Ganga and Yamuna at the foot.
  • Pranala: the spout draining the sanctum, a channelled trough ending in a makara head over a stone basin.
Before After
Temple doorway before Temple doorway after

Mughal and Deccan

  • Muqarnas: tiers of small faceted cells lining the half-dome of the great arched recesses (iwans).
  • Inscription bands: black lettering inlaid in white marble round the frames.
  • Inlaid borders of white marble with small lozenges, glazed tile bands at Sher Shah's tomb and the Qutb Shahi tombs, and the petal ring round the Gol Gumbaz.
  • Bangla roofs, curved both ways, with the ridge and eaves drooping to the corners, as on Agra Fort's gilded pavilions and the Red Fort's jharokha.
  • Chadar: the Mughal garden cascade, a sloping marble bed carved in fish scales under a thin sheet of water.
Before After
Iwan before Iwan after

Forts

  • Machicolations: boxes projecting from the head of a wall, with a slot in the floor for dropping stones on attackers.
  • Gun-loops in the merlons.
  • String courses and arrow slits on Mehrangarh's walls, and two rings of slits round each of Jaisalmer's 99 bastions.

Tibetan monasteries

  • Penbey parapets: the maroon band of packed twigs under the roof.
  • Framed hall windows with awnings, projecting timber window bays, galleries of brass prayer wheels, and gilded roofs with lotus-and-vase finials, upturned corners and bells.

Colonial

  • Louvred shutters at Cooch Behar Palace, and glazing behind the sun-breakers of Chandigarh's Capitol.

New surfaces

Some detail is too fine for geometry, so it's drawn by the surface shader instead:

  • Copper and gilded copper: staggered sheets with standing seams and hammer dimples, and verdigris along the seams on plain copper. Used on gilt roofs such as Kashi Vishwanath's and Tirumala's.
  • Terracotta: thin fired bricks, each its own shade with the odd one over-burnt, stained by soot and lichen. It fades to an even tone in the distance so it never shimmers. Used on Nalanda, the Dhamek Stupa, Ramappa's tower and the Cellular Jail.
  • Terracotta plaques: bands of moulded tiles with a lotus or a standing figure in turn.
  • Marble cladding that follows a curved shell, for the Lotus Temple's petals.
  • Granite blocks with their joints showing, for Thiruvalluvar.

Terracotta brick and plaques

Mysore Palace, rebuilt from a photograph

Mysore Palace got the biggest single change. It was a compact block with its tower standing out in front. It's now built to the proportions of the photographed front, about 125 m across and 44 m to the spire:

  • A ground floor with a row of small arches, and above it the Durbar Hall's arcade of wide cusped arches on paired granite columns over a pierced railing.
  • A gallery of small arched windows, and a balustraded parapet with red-domed kiosks.
  • The central bay standing forward with three arched windows and a gable in its red horseshoe hood, where the gilt Gajalakshmi sits between her elephants.
  • The central tower set back over the roof with its gilt dome and spire, and two grey domes on their kiosks.
  • At each end, two pink-brown granite towers with stacked oriels and crimson onion domes.
  • In front, the red-brick drive between green hoop railings, globe lamps and beds of red flowers.
Before After
Mysore Palace before Mysore Palace after

Other monuments that got the most

More than forty monuments were improved. Here are some of the biggest changes.

Meenakshi Temple went from about 600k triangles to close to 800k on desktops. Its two shrine halls stand on moulded bases with pilasters, a curved eave and a parapet of miniature shrines. The Golden Lotus Tank has its pillared cloister. Every pillar in the corridors and the Thousand Pillar Hall has a base, a capital and a bracket. All fourteen gopurams have denser stucco figures.

Before After
Meenakshi before Meenakshi after

Buland Darwaza: the arched recesses on the gate's two angled wings used to be placed sideways, buried inside the wall. They now face out towards the town in two tiers, each in a white marble border under merlons. There are also panelled piers, screened windows, muqarnas in the great iwan, and buttressed walls on the ridge.

The Jyotirlinga temples:

  • Trimbakeshwar and Bhimashankar have Nandi mandapas and deepmalas.
  • Grishneshwar's court, which had no entrance, has a gatehouse.
  • Kashi Vishwanath has blind arches, merlon parapets and a framed Ganga gate under gilt roofs.
  • Baidyanath has the red silk gathbandhan threads tied between Shiva's and Parvati's spires.
  • Mallikarjuna has a pillared porch, the gold flagstaff and a Nandi mandapa.
  • Somnath has its sea-wall promenade, the Baan Stambh (with its arrow pointing out to sea) and the Digvijay Dwar.
  • Kedarnath has Adi Shankaracharya in his pool, and Omkareshwar the Statue of Oneness.
Before After
Grishneshwar before Grishneshwar after
Before After
Somnath before Somnath after

Kerala and the south:

  • Padmanabhaswamy has Kerala gables, eave struts, a wall of oil lamps (vilakkumadam) lit at night and tiled coping.
  • Tirumala has a gilt sanctum, the Sampangi colonnade and the Neerazhi mandapam in its tank.
  • Ramanathaswamy has dressed walls and corridors.
  • The Shore Temple has a moulded base and water spout.

Jain sites:

  • Palitana and Shikharji have moulded shrines, doorways and manastambhas.
  • Soniji ki Nasiyan has pilasters, carved bands and cusped arches.

Forts and palaces:

  • Hawa Mahal has the white lime trim that outlines its pink façade.
  • Agra Fort has its river front and Khas Mahal.
  • Bekal has a cannon, magazine and temple.
  • Chittorgarh has ruined palaces and temples.
  • Fatehpur Sikri's Panch Mahal has carved columns.

Colonial and modern buildings:

  • Victoria Memorial and CSMT have their allegories, and CSMT's gate piers were lengthened to hold the lion and tiger.
  • India Gate has Netaji under the canopy, and the National War Memorial its Lion Capital.
  • The Lotus Temple has panels, ribs and copings on its petals.

An 800k budget, spent on buildings

From the start, every monument had to stay under 650,000 triangles on desktops and 300,000 on phones. With this much new detail, the temples ran out of room first and then everything else did. The desktop budget is now 800,000 for every monument. Phones stay at 300,000.

The important part is what the extra 150k may be spent on. Trees and ground cover are still planted only up to 650k, so the extra room goes to the architecture and not to more palm trees:

// The budget is for the buildings: trees and ground cover are planted only up to PLANT,
// 650k on desktops, so the extra goes to the architecture.
export const BUDGET = { high: 800000, low: 300000 };
export const PLANT  = { high: 650000, low: 300000 };

export function budgetFor(m, level = detail.level) {
  return BUDGET[level];
}

Phones keep the plain masses: the fine heads, carved jambs, ship fittings and arrow slits are desktop-only, and phones get coarser statues, light robed allegories and every other car. Every monument is still built at both levels and counted by a budget checker that fails if anything goes over. For example, the rebuilt Mysore Palace comes in at 509k on desktops and 290k on phones, and the Victoria Memorial at 651k and 277k. Other checks catch flickering surfaces (two faces fighting over the same plane) and buildings that come out taller than the real thing.

What's next

The pattern that worked here was to look at photographs, find what's missing, and put anything more than one building needs into the shared kit. For the statues it went one step further: every one was set beside its photographs and corrected until the pose, the clothes and the proportions matched, and the stand-ins borrowed from the kit were replaced. The next step is to do the same for the buildings that are still closer to massing models than to the photograph, the way Mysore Palace was rebuilt here.

If you like the project, a ⭐ on the GitHub repo helps other people find it.

Further reading in the repo:

Which monument, statue or animal still looks least like itself to you? Tell me in the comments.

Chat with me